Wednesday, December 18, 2019

UPDATE: TMX Court Case - Canada's Scientists agree "there is insufficient information on the behaviour of diluted bitumen to adequately address the risk of oil spill and clean up"

Canoeists paddle first nation canoes past the Kinder Morgan facility in Burrard Inlet in North Vancouver, B.C. Thursday, May, 22, 2014.Four British Columbia Indigenous groups are set to argue in the Federal Court of Appeal that the Canadian government failed to consult adequately with them before its latest approval of the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward

Back when I was a social worker, our team went on a cultural day to the First Nations community involved in the legal process described below.  As part of that experience we went out on the two canoes shown above and then returned to the lodge where our guides spoke to us about the history of the First Nations in Burrard Inlet.  They told us about an ancient sacred burial ground in the forests that bordered the Inlet.  The bodies of the dead were put in wooden and woven baskets and hung from the huge cedars--where now there is a natural gas refinery and an electrical transmission park.  They told us that back "in the day" large pods of killer whales regularly came down the Inlet from the Pacific Ocean to feed on salmon from the surrounding salmon streams [many no longer in existence].  It was an illuminating and sobering experience.

Now, these same First Nations are fighting for what's left of Burrard Inlet in the Federal Court of Canada.  They are fighting the Canadian government, which is using duplicity to ram an ecologically devastating pipeline expansion and oil tanker port down their throats.  Below, is the latest report I could find on the court hearing which is taking place before the Federal Court of Appeal this week.  Please read and I will have more comments to follow:

First, I ask my readers:  Would you impose this risk on a neighbour or a member of your family?!


First Nation alleges Ottawa withheld info during Trans Mountain consultation

The Canadian Press

December 16, 2019 01:00 AM

VANCOUVER — A lawyer for a British Columbia First Nation is accusing the federal government of withholding key information about oil spills until after the latest consultation on the Trans Mountain pipeline was over.

Scott Smith, who represents the Tsleil-Waututh Nation, told the Federal Court of Appeal in Vancouver on Monday that the First Nation prepared three expert reports on the risks of oil spills and other environmental concerns surrounding the pipeline expansion.

A federal peer review of the reports effectively agreed with their findings that there is a lack of information about the effects and behaviour of diluted bitumen, but it wasn't shared with the First Nation until after consultation closed, Smith said

"Meaningful dialogue cannot occur where, as here, Canada withheld key documents until after the decision and refused to change its position even when its scientists agreed," Smith said.

He also alleges the peer review was "substantially altered" before it was distributed with a note saying a report on diluted bitumen was not necessary to cabinet's vote on the pipeline, effectively neutering the scientists' conclusions.

The Tsleil-Waututh are among four B.C. Indigenous groups arguing in the court this week that the Canadian government came into the new round of consultations having predetermined the outcome before its latest approval of the Trans Mountain pipeline.

The Federal Court of Appeal tore up the government's original approval of the pipeline in August 2018, citing inadequate Indigenous consultation among its reasons.

Lawyers for the Canadian government are expected to present arguments Tuesday.

Smith argued that Ottawa had already made up its mind about whether to approve the pipeline again before renewing the consultation. He pointed to public comments made by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau after the court quashed its initial approval, in which he said the project is in the "national interest," as well as similar comments made by cabinet ministers.

"Canada simply refused to budge on any of these issues or change its position because it was unilaterally focused on reapproving the project and in the words of the minister of finance, 'getting shovels into the ground,' " Smith said.

The result was another round of consultations that was "fundamentally flawed" before Ottawa's latest approval of the pipeline expansion, he said.

Lawyers for the Coldwater Indian Band and a coalition of small First Nations in the Fraser Valley also presented arguments Monday.

Matthew Kirchner told the panel of three judges that the existing Trans Mountain pipeline cuts through the heart of the Coldwater reserve 12 kilometres southwest of Merritt in B.C.'s Interior.

The reserve relies entirely on the underlying aquifer for its drinking water and Ottawa has a fiduciary duty to protect it, he said.

"It is hard to conceive of an issue that is more fundamental, and of more fundamental importance to repairing Canada's damaged relationship with Indigenous Peoples, than that of the protection of drinking water on reserve," Kirchner told the court.

The band has requested a hydrogeological study since 2015, beginning with a two-year baseline report, in order to understand impacts on the aquifer.

Only two weeks before cabinet voted on the project, the Crown consultant emailed the First Nation's chief on a Friday night providing him with vital information about how the aquifer would be analyzed and how a possible alternate route would be assessed, he said.

The chief was given until only the following Wednesday to provide a response, Kirchner said.

"There is no opportunity at all in there for meaningful dialogue," he said.

The proposal set an arbitrary deadline for an aquifer assessment of Dec. 31, neglecting the two-year baseline review requested, he said.

"Canada and Trans Mountain continue to try to cut corners," Kirchner alleged.

The three-day hearing is scheduled to continue through Wednesday to consider legal challenges launched by the Tsleil-Waututh Nation, Squamish Nation, Coldwater Indian Band and a coalition of small First Nations in the Fraser Valley.

Several First Nations, environmental groups and the City of Vancouver had originally filed challenges making a range of arguments including that the project threatens southern resident killer whales.
The court only allowed six First Nations to proceed and called for an expedited hearing focused on the federal government's consultation with Indigenous communities between August 2018 and June 2019.

Two First Nations have since dropped out of the appeal after signing deals with Trans Mountain Corp., the Crown corporation that operates the pipeline and is building the expansion.

The Tsleil-Waututh and environmental groups filed leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, arguing that a broader hearing was necessary, but the high court has not yet issued a decision.

Trudeau's government has twice approved a plan to triple the capacity of the pipeline from Alberta's oilsands to a shipping terminal in Metro Vancouver. [in Burrard Inlet]
After the Federal Court of Appeal nixed the original approval, the Liberal government ordered the forerunner of the Canada Energy Regulator to conduct a new review focusing on marine impacts, which was completed in February.

The government also appointed retired Supreme Court justice Frank Iacobucci [previously embroiled in the SNL corruption scandal as a Liberal 'fixer'] to oversee a new phase of consultation with affected Indigenous communities before it approved the project a second time in June.

The governments of Alberta and Saskatchewan, which support the pipeline expansion, have joined the case as interveners.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 16, 2019.


Greencrow says:
  You won't be reading about this case in today's mainZtream media.  That owned and operated corporatist mouthpiece is rattling on about the Trump impeachment vote all day, dontchaknow.  Meanwhile, all manner of sleight-of-hand political machinations are taking place in North America.  This is only one.  I have another post circling the landing field in a holding pattern that talks about how the Trudeau Liberals have sold our security and sovereignty to the US in the new NAFTA agreement.

It is not by accident that all of this TMX bullshit is coming to a head at Christmas and at a time of year when people are not paying close attention to what the congenital swindlers are up to.  The timing is as planned as were the efforts of the Federal Government described by the First Nations lawyers above to hide the report of the scientists that says that absolutely NOBODY KNOWS HOW TO CLEAN UP DILUTED BITUMEN.  Least of all the Alberta oil corporations--who don't even clean up the messes left from their abandoned oil wells in that province!

So I have yet another "make work" project for the corporate welfare bums who are so desperate to destroy the Province of British Columbia.  Why doesn't the Federal Government of Canada give the corporations mega billion$ in tax dollars to clean up all the 93,000 "orphan oil wells" and the horrific tar sands messes?  That will keep all the Oil Companies solvent, Albertans working and Canada united.  You don't HAVE to be destroying something to be making money...dontchaknow.

HERE is the Trans Mountain/Canadian government response to the First Nations arguments.


Anonymous said...

Hi Greencrow,

Keep up the good work.

My father grew up in Brentwood Bay in the late 1920's, he told me how he and his father went rowing near Senanus Island in Saanich Inlet and they could see the cedar boxes placed in the trees.

greencrow said...

Hi Anonymous:

Thanks for your support. My vision is that Burrard Inlet and Indian Arm be declared a marine park with intense focus on restoration of salmon and other marine/coastal habitat.


Reading between the lines said...

All for the sake of $$ ,we run the risk of destroying the natural habitat of land and sea life for the foreseeable future should the pipeline be breached .And it will someday .What to say other than we are being run by fools and not leaders .

greencrow said...

Ironically, RBTL, the species known as "leaders" is going extinct faster than any other living thing.

wallflower said...

Just found this: